§708-874 Misapplication of entrusted property. (1) A person commits the offense of misapplication of entrusted property if, with knowledge that he is misapplying property and that the misapplication involves substantial risk of loss or detriment to the owner of the property or to a person for whose benefit the property was entrusted, he misapplies or disposes of property that has been entrusted to him as a fiduciary or that is property of the government or a financial institution.
(2) "Fiduciary" includes a trustee, guardian, personal representative, receiver, or any other person acting in a fiduciary capacity, or any person carrying on fiduciary functions on behalf of a corporation or other organization which is a fiduciary.
(3) To "misapply property" means to deal with the property contrary to law or governmental regulation relating to the custody or disposition of that property; "governmental regulation" includes administrative and judicial rules and orders as well as statutes and ordinances.
(4) Misapplication of property is a misdemeanor. [L 1972, c 9, pt of §1; am L 1976, c 200, pt of §1]
COMMENTARY ON §708-874
This section is intended to discourage both knowing violation of fiduciary obligations and knowing misapplication of property belonging either to the government or to a financial institution. In this context the misapplication is in terms of improper and reckless investment or handling of assets, rather than of outright theft. For purposes of this section, a fiduciary includes any person (including a corporation) acting in a fiduciary capacity for another person, and a person acting in a fiduciary capacity on behalf of a corporation or organization which is itself a fiduciary. The requirement of knowledge extends to the substantial risk of loss or detriment to the owner.
Misapplication in this context is not theft; there is no intent permanently to deprive the owner of the owner's property. Moreover, the actor does not misappropriate funds, unless there is a specific duty to make payment to someone else. The danger envisioned is the risk "that one who administers or controls the property may deliberately depart from the legal rules applicable to his control of the property in question and may gamble with the property at considerable known risk to the safety of the property in question."[1]
Existing law provides that a trust company that violates, neglects, or refuses to comply with statutory requirements relating to trusts, and an officer, manager, director, or employee who knowingly participates in such violation, commits a misdemeanor if it or he, as the case may be, fails to desist from the practice within seven days following notification by the Director of the Department of Regulatory Agencies.2 The provision is designed to accomplish certain regulatory ends. The Penal Code does not propose to abolish the regulatory provision; it will, however, in aggravated cases, provide for a direct, unconditional penalty. Where (1) the actor acts knowingly (as opposed to negligently), and (2) the violation of a statutory or administrative requirement amounts to a misapplication of entrusted property (as opposed to violating some other requirement related to trust administration), the warning period is eliminated. There is no need for a warning period if criminal liability is not strictly imposed or predicated on negligence.
Law Journals and Reviews
Student Symposium: Legal Malpractice, 14 HBJ, no. 1, at 3 (1978).
Case Notes
No private right of action exists under this section; therefore, plaintiffs cannot state a claim under the section. 131 H. 62, 315 P.3d 213 (2013).
__________
§708-874 Commentary:
1. Prop. Mich. Rev. Cr. Code, comments at 302.
2. H.R.S. §406-61.
Structure Hawaii Revised Statutes
708. Offenses Against Property Rights
708-800 Definitions of terms in this chapter.
708-801 Valuation of property or services.
708-802 Property recovered in offenses against property rights.
708-803 Habitual property crime.
708-804 Control of albizia trees on private property.
708-810 Burglary in the first degree.
708-811 Burglary in the second degree. § §708-810 And 708-811 Commentary:
708-812 Possession of burglar's tools.
708-812.6 Unauthorized entry in a dwelling in the second degree.
708-812.55 Unauthorized entry in a dwelling in the first degree.
708-813 Criminal trespass in the first degree.
708-814 Criminal trespass in the second degree.
708-814.5 Criminal trespass onto public parks and recreational grounds.
708-814.7 Criminal trespass onto state lands.
708-815 Simple trespass. § §708-813 To 708-815 Commentary:
708-817 Burglary of a dwelling during an emergency period.
708-818 Burglary of a building during an emergency period.
708-820 Criminal property damage in the first degree.
708-821 Criminal property damage in the second degree.
708-822 Criminal property damage in the third degree.
708-823 Criminal property damage in the fourth degree. § §708-820 To 708-823 Commentary:
708-823.5 Aggravated criminal property damage.
708-823.6 Graffiti; sentencing.
708-824 Failure to control widely dangerous means. §708-824 Commentary:
708-825 Criminal tampering; definitions of terms.
708-826 Criminal tampering in the first degree.
708-827 Criminal tampering in the second degree.
708-828 Criminal use of a noxious substance. §708-828 Commentary:
708-829 Criminal littering. §708-829 Commentary:
708-830.5 Theft in the first degree.
708-831 Theft in the second degree.
708-832 Theft in the third degree.
708-833 Theft in the fourth degree. § §708-830 To 708-833 Commentary:
708-835 Proof of theft offense. §708-835 Commentary:
708-835.4 Unauthorized operation of a recording device in a motion picture theater.
708-835.6 Telemarketing fraud.
708-835.55 Theft; agricultural product; sentencing.
708-836 Unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle in the first degree. §708-836 Commentary:
708-836.1 Unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle in the second degree.
708-836.5 Unauthorized entry into motor vehicle in the first degree.
708-836.6 Unauthorized entry into motor vehicle in the second degree.
708-837 Failure to return a rental motor vehicle; penalty.
708-837.5 Failure to return leased or rented personal property; penalty.
708-838 Removal of identification marks.
708-839.6 Identity theft in the first degree.
708-839.55 Unauthorized possession of confidential personal information.
708-840 Robbery in the first degree.
708-841 Robbery in the second degree. § §708-840 And 708-841 Commentary:
708-842 Robbery; "in the course of committing a theft". §708-842 Commentary:
708-850 Definitions of terms in this part.
708-851 Forgery in the first degree.
708-852 Forgery in the second degree.
708-853 Forgery in the third degree. § §708-851 To 708-853 Commentary:
708-854 Criminal possession of a forgery device.
708-856 Obtaining signature by deception.
708-857 Negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument. §708-857 Commentary:
708-858 Suppressing a testamentary or recordable instrument.
708-870 Deceptive business practices. §708-870 Commentary:
708-871 False advertising. §708-871 Commentary:
708-871.5 False labeling of Hawaii-grown coffee.
708-872 Falsifying business records. §708-872 Commentary:
708-873 Defrauding secured creditors. §708-873 Commentary:
708-874 Misapplication of entrusted property. §708-874 Commentary:
708-875 Trademark counterfeiting.
708-880 Commercial bribery. §708-880 Commentary:
708-881 Tampering with a publicly-exhibited contest. §708-881 Commentary:
708-890 to 708-896 REPEALED. §708-890 Definitions.
708-891 to 708-893 OLD REPEALED. §708-891 Computer fraud in the first degree.
708-891.5 Computer fraud in the second degree.
708-891.6 Computer fraud in the third degree.
708-892 Computer damage in the first degree.
708-892.5 Computer damage in the second degree.
708-892.6 Computer damage in the third degree.
708-893 Use of a computer in the commission of a separate crime.
708-894 Forfeiture of property used in computer crimes.
708-895.5 Unauthorized computer access in the first degree.
708-895.6 Unauthorized computer access in the second degree.
708-895.7 Unauthorized computer access in the third degree.
708-8100 Fraudulent use of a credit card.
708-8101 Making a false statement to procure issuance of a credit card.
708-8102 Theft, forgery, etc., of credit cards.
708-8103 Credit card fraud by a provider of goods or services.
708-8104 Possession of unauthorized credit card machinery or incomplete cards.
708-8105 Credit card lists prohibited; penalty.
708-8106 Defenses not available.
708-8120 and 708-8121 REPEALED.
708-8200 Cable television service fraud in the first degree.
708-8201 Cable television service fraud in the second degree.
708-8202 Telecommunication service fraud in the first degree.
708-8203 Telecommunication service fraud in the second degree.
708-8204 Forfeiture of telecommunication service device and cable television service device.
708-8251 Arson in the first degree.
708-8252 Arson in the second degree.
708-8253 Arson in the third degree.
708-8254 Arson in the fourth degree.
708-8300 Unlicensed contracting activity.
708-8301 Habitual unlicensed contracting activity; felony.
708-8302 Unlicensed contractor fraud.
708-8303 Unlicensed contractor fraud in the first degree.
708-8304 Unlicensed contractor fraud in the second degree.
708-8305 Unlicensed contractor fraud; valuation of property.