Ohio Revised Code
Chapter 4909 | Public Utilities Commission - Fixation of Rates
Section 4909.39 | Findings as to Rate - Valuation of Property.

Effective: September 28, 1979
Latest Legislation: House Bill 156 - 113th General Assembly
If the public utilities commission, after the hearing referred to in sections 4909.34 to 4909.36 of the Revised Code, is of the opinion that the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental, so fixed by ordinance is or will be unjust, unreasonable, or insufficient to yield reasonable compensation for the service, the commission shall fix and determine the just and reasonable rate, price, charge, toll, or rental to be charged, demanded, exacted, or collected by such public utility during the period so fixed by ordinance, which period shall not be less than two years, and order the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental so fixed substituted for the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental fixed by ordinance. The commission may find and declare that the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental, so fixed by ordinance, is just and reasonable, and ratify and confirm it.
No rate, price, charge, toll, or rental so determined by the commission shall become effective until after the commission has ascertained and determined the valuation upon which such price, charge, toll, or rental is based. Such valuation, so determined, shall be at all times open to public inspection. Thereupon the commission shall make inquiry and investigation with respect to the ability of such public utility to furnish its product during such period. If it is found that the public utility is able to do so, the commission shall order it to continue to furnish such product for the period and at the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental so fixed and determined, and such public utility shall continue to furnish its product as provided in such order. If the commission, after the hearing provided for in this section and sections 4909.34 to 4909.36 of the Revised Code, is of the opinion that any provisions of the ordinance or ordinances appealed from or complained of other than the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental fixed by such ordinance or ordinances are or will be unjust or unreasonable or that the form and structure of the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental fixed by such ordinance or ordinances may be unfair or unreasonable, or may have the effect of causing any rate, price, charge, toll, or rental to be fixed by the commission to become unfair or unreasonable, the commission shall, in its order, strike out such unjust or unreasonable provisions, conditions, form, and structure of said ordinance or ordinances and shall substitute for them, if it deems it necessary, such provisions and conditions as it considers fair and reasonable, and make such changes in the form and structure of the rate, price, charge, toll, or rental fixed in such ordinance or ordinances as it considers fair and reasonable.
In fulfillment of its duties under this section as to what constitutes an unjust, unreasonable, or insufficient rate, price, charge, toll, or rental, as to what constitutes a just and reasonable rate, price, charge, toll, or rental, as to what constitutes an unjust or unreasonable rate, price, charge, toll, or rental, or, insofar as the form and structure of any rate, price, charge, toll, or rental is concerned, as to what may have the effect of causing it to become unfair and unreasonable, the decision of the commission shall be based on the factors stated in section 4909.15 of the Revised Code.

Structure Ohio Revised Code

Ohio Revised Code

Title 49 | Public Utilities

Chapter 4909 | Public Utilities Commission - Fixation of Rates

Section 4909.01 | Public Utilities Commission - Fixation of Rates Definitions.

Section 4909.02 | Regulations and Practices Prescribed by Commission Prima-Facie Reasonable.

Section 4909.03 | Effect of Rates Fixed by Commission.

Section 4909.04 | Valuation of Property to Determine Justice of Rates.

Section 4909.05 | Report of Valuation of Property.

Section 4909.051 | Definitions for Sections 4909.052 to 4909.055.

Section 4909.052 | Evaluation of Petition for Purchase of Municipal Water-Works or Sewage Disposal System; Acceptance of Cost Report.

Section 4909.053 | Appraisals.

Section 4909.054 | List of Utility-Valuation Experts.

Section 4909.055 | Cost of Obtaining Valuations.

Section 4909.057 | Deferral of Post-in-Service Carrying Costs.

Section 4909.059 | Construction of Sections.

Section 4909.06 | Additional Facts.

Section 4909.07 | Revision and Correction of Valuations.

Section 4909.08 | Notice and Hearing Before Valuation Becomes Final.

Section 4909.09 | Ascertainment of Valuation.

Section 4909.10 | Hearing to Ascertain Value of Property - Notice.

Section 4909.11 | Filing and Review of Findings.

Section 4909.12 | Admissibility of Findings in Evidence.

Section 4909.13 | Additional Hearings.

Section 4909.14 | Wrongful Valuation.

Section 4909.15 | Fixation of Reasonable Rate.

Section 4909.151 | Consideration of Costs Attributable to Service.

Section 4909.152 | Consideration of Efficiency, Sufficiency, Adequacy of Facilities.

Section 4909.153 | Hearing Service Complaints.

Section 4909.154 | Consideration of Management Policies, Practices, and Organization of Public Utility.

Section 4909.155 | Filing Report on Bonds, Stock and Money.

Section 4909.156 | Filing Report Showing Property Valuation.

Section 4909.16 | Power to Amend, Alter, or Suspend Schedule of Rates.

Section 4909.161 | Recovering Increased Excise Tax Levy and Kilowatt-Hour Tax.

Section 4909.17 | Approval Required for Change in Rate.

Section 4909.171 | Basing Waterworks Rate Charge on Change in Water Cost Imposed by Local Government.

Section 4909.172 | Application for Approval to Collect Infrastructure Improvement Surcharge.

Section 4909.18 | Application to Establish or Change Rate.

Section 4909.19 | Publication of Notice - Investigation.

Section 4909.191 | Submission of Rate or Charge Adjustments or Recalculations After Actual Data Acquired.

Section 4909.20 | Regulation of Freight Charges.

Section 4909.21 | Rules and Regulations Relative to Carload Shipments of Livestock.

Section 4909.22 | Rates Shall Be Just and Reasonable.

Section 4909.23 | Special Contract Rates.

Section 4909.24 | Complaints and Hearings.

Section 4909.25 | Separate Hearings.

Section 4909.26 | Commission May Change Unreasonable Rate.

Section 4909.27 | Investigating Rates Upon Its Own Motion.

Section 4909.28 | Commission May Change Rate or Service.

Section 4909.29 | Copies of Orders to Be Supplied Railroad.

Section 4909.30 | Commission May Rescind or Amend an Order.

Section 4909.31 | Supplemental Order as to Railroads.

Section 4909.32 | Commission May Fix Joint Rate.

Section 4909.33 | Supplemental Order as to Public Utilities.

Section 4909.34 | Power of Municipal Corporation or Group of Corporations to Fix Rate, Price, and Charge.

Section 4909.35 | Failure of Municipal Corporation to Fix Rates.

Section 4909.36 | Hearing Upon Accepted Rates - Procedure.

Section 4909.37 | Hearing Where Cause of Action Arose.

Section 4909.38 | Complaint, Appeal, or Notification Requirements.

Section 4909.39 | Findings as to Rate - Valuation of Property.

Section 4909.40 | Certain Rates, Fares, Regulations, and Prices Excepted.

Section 4909.41 | Violation.

Section 4909.42 | Commission Fails to Issue Timely Order.

Section 4909.43 | Filing Rate Increase Application.

Section 4909.45 | Information Furnished by Gas or Natural Gas Company to Municipal Corporation.

Section 4909.99 | Penalty.